Photo by George Dolgikh on <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/woman-wearing-blue-jacket-sitting-on-chair-near-table-reading-books-1326947/" rel="nofollow">Pexels.com</a>
Effective teaching and learning are much more than delivering content and hoping it sticks. To maximize learning, educators need to understand how students progress through different phases of learning—surface, deep, and transfer—and tailor strategies to match each phase. Drawing on insights from John Hattie, Douglas Fisher, and Nancy Frey’s Visible Learning for Mathematics (2017), this blog explores these learning phases and offers practical strategies to enhance classroom impact.
1. Surface Learning: The Foundation
What It Is:
Surface learning is often misunderstood as shallow or superficial, but it forms the essential foundation of all learning. It’s the phase where students are first exposed to new concepts, skills, and strategies. Without a strong grasp of this initial knowledge, deeper understanding cannot occur.
Strategies for Surface Learning:
At this stage, strategies should focus on acquisition and consolidation.
- Acquisition Strategies: Highlighting, note-taking, mnemonics, underlining, and imagery.
- Consolidation Strategies: Rehearsal, practice tests, and learning to receive feedback effectively.
Why It Matters:
Surface learning provides students with the raw materials—the facts, vocabulary, and basic processes—that they will later refine and apply.
2. Deep Learning: Moving Beyond the Basics
What It Is:
Deep learning is where students take their foundational knowledge and begin to organize, analyze, and apply it. It’s the “sweet spot” where students consolidate their understanding and make connections between ideas.
Strategies for Deep Learning:
Educators should encourage metacognition and critical thinking through these strategies:
- Acquisition Strategies: Concept mapping, strategy monitoring, and organization.
- Consolidation Strategies: Self-questioning, peer tutoring, collaboration, self-explanation, and critical thinking exercises.
Why It Matters:
Deep learning bridges surface-level knowledge and higher-order thinking, enabling students to grasp complex ideas and prepare for real-world applications.
3. Transfer Learning: The Ultimate Goal
What It Is:
Transfer learning is when students apply their consolidated knowledge to new contexts and scenarios. This phase demonstrates mastery and the ability to think metacognitively—reflecting on and regulating their learning process.
Strategies for Transfer Learning:
Encourage students to:
- Solve unfamiliar problems using previously learned strategies.
- Reflect on their learning and how it applies to broader contexts.
- Engage in project-based learning (PBL) after sufficient surface and deep learning preparation.
Why It Matters:
Transfer learning is where students move beyond the classroom, using their knowledge and skills to navigate complex, real-world challenges.
The Role of Learning Intentions and Success Criteria
Hattie and Donoghue emphasize the importance of learning intentions and success criteria at every stage. When students understand what they are learning, why it matters, and how they will succeed, their learning is significantly enhanced. Key practices include:
- Providing clear success criteria.
- Setting standards for self-judgment.
- Planning and goal-setting with students.
The Big Takeaway
Matching the right teaching strategies to the appropriate phase of learning is critical. As Hattie, Fisher, and Frey argue, “What and when are equally important.” For example:
- Surface strategies may be ineffective for deep learning and vice versa.
- Jumping straight into transfer tasks, such as PBL, without sufficient foundational knowledge can hinder progress.
By focusing on surface, deep, and transfer learning—along with the strategies best suited for each—educators can create a classroom environment that promotes lasting engagement, understanding, and success.
Time to Reflect and Collaborate
Imagine transforming faculty meetings into spaces where educators discuss how to move students through these phases, instead of focusing solely on pacing or testing. Questions like, “How can we better support transfer learning?” and “What strategies work best for consolidating deep learning?” can inspire meaningful change.
By aligning strategies with learning phases, educators not only enhance student outcomes but also create a more engaging and purposeful teaching experience. Let’s move beyond merely teaching; let’s teach to transform.